One of our favorite things to do when we travel is find little witchy shops, so we stopped into My Cauldron Too on Spanish St.
Tucked away in the heart of the nation’s oldest city, this enchanting metaphysical shop is a must-visit for anyone drawn to crystals, herbs, tarot, or simply a little everyday magic.
A Hidden Gem on Spanish Street
Located at 58 Spanish Street, My Cauldron Too has become a favorite stop for both locals and visitors exploring St. Augustine’s historic district. While the city is famous for its centuries-old architecture, ghost tours, and haunted history, this charming shop adds another layer of mystique to your visit.
From the moment you step inside, you’re greeted by the earthy scent of herbs and incense, shelves filled with colorful crystals and displays of handcrafted spiritual tools.
The shop opens every day at 12:00 p.m. and is closed on Tuesdays. This shop is the sister store of My Cauldron, located in Deland, FL.
What You’ll Find Inside
On our visit to My Cauldron Too, the main section had a lot of different items, but overall, not a large selection.
The shelves seemed a bit emptier than I expected, so they may have been due for a restock. I visited hoping to find a unique tarot deck, but the selection was smaller than I had anticipated.
There is an area in the back where they do tarot readings. We asked about the price, and I think it was quoted at $1.50 a minute. We thought the pricing was a bit odd since usually it’s a flat rate.
Some of the items you’ll discover include:
- Crystals and gemstones
- Dried herbs and herbal blends
- Loose teas
- Incense
- Candles
- Tarot and oracle decks
- Books on witchcraft, herbalism, and spirituality
- Ritual supplies
- Handmade soaps
- Jewelry
- Cauldrons and altar accessories
One cute thing to point out- they have shopping cauldrons instead of baskets:
The Best Part: Fresh Herbs
The shop is especially known for its extensive herb selection, making it a favorite among green witches, herbalists, and anyone interested in natural wellness traditions.
And this is where we were really impressed! The herb shop is off the left, and the man running that area was very knowledgeable and passionate about his herbs.
The herbs range from the obscure to everyday herbs like garlic. I bought some spice to go on veggies, and Heather bought some kind of dream tea herb. Everything smelled amazing!
It’s all in large jars and they weigh out how much you want. It’s then put in a plastic baggie and labeled.
A Perfect Stop During a Haunted St. Augustine Adventure
St. Augustine has long been considered one of America’s most haunted cities. Between ghost tours, historic cemeteries, and centuries of legends, it’s easy to embrace the city’s supernatural side.
Adding My Cauldron Too to your itinerary feels like a natural extension of that experience.
After wandering through the Castillo de San Marcos, visiting the Old Jail, or taking an evening ghost tour, stepping into this magical little shop helps round out a day filled with history and mystery.
Tips Before You Visit
Before stopping by, keep these tips in mind:
- The shop is located in historic downtown St. Augustine, so paid parking may be required.
- Weekends can be busy, especially during tourist season.
- Give yourself plenty of time to browse—you’ll likely notice something new every lap around the store.
- If you’re shopping for crystals or herbs, don’t hesitate to ask questions. The staff is known for being helpful.
- Store hours may vary by season, so it’s a good idea to check before making a special trip.
- Don’t leave without sniffing the herbs!
And when you are done shopping, or if you have people waiting for you while you shop, they have a cute little front porch with comfy chairs!
Leave a Reply